Bioethical Dilemma and Medicolegal Implications in the Management of Pulmonary Tuberculosis: A Professional and Humanistic Review

Authors

  • Siti Lukmanah

Abstract

Background: Tuberculosis (TB) remains a major global health problem with high incidence and
mortality rates, including in Indonesia, which ranks as the second-highest TB burden country
worldwide. The prolonged duration of TB treatment is often challenged by patient non-adherence, social
stigma, and conflicts between individual rights and public health interests. These conditions give rise
to bioethical dilemmas and medicolegal implications in clinical practice.
Objective: To analyze bioethical dilemmas and medicolegal implications in the management of
pulmonary tuberculosis through a professionalism and humanistic approach based on a clinical case
illustration.
Case Illustration: A 42-year-old male with smear-positive pulmonary TB demonstrated poor
adherence to treatment, refused to wear a mask, and objected to contact tracing due to concerns about
social stigma and economic pressure. The patient was lost to follow-up in the second week of therapy
due to drug side effects and work demands, thereby increasing the risk of disease transmission and
drug resistance.
Discussion: This case highlights a conflict between bioethical principles, particularly patient
autonomy versus beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice. In the context of infectious diseases,
limitations on autonomy may be justified to protect public health. From a medicolegal perspective,
healthcare providers have obligations for reporting and contact tracing in accordance with national
regulations. A humanistic approach is essential to improve treatment adherence through empathetic
communication, family-based education, and social advocacy to address social determinants of health.
The integration of professionalism and humanism enhances patient trust and long-term treatment
success.
Conclusion: The management of pulmonary tuberculosis requires a balance between respecting patient
autonomy and protecting public health. Professionalism combined with a humanistic approach is
essential to address bioethical dilemmas and minimize medicolegal risks, while improving treatment
adherence and therapeutic outcomes.
Keywords: Pulmonary tuberculosis, bioethics, medicolegal, professionalism, humanistic approach.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Downloads

Published

2026-04-11