Perbandingan Kepastian Hukum Transseksual Antara Negara Republik Indonesia dan Republik Islam Iran

  • Andria Marchelia Universitas Airlangga
  • Muhammad Dzulfikar Syaiful Ali Universitas Airlangga
Keywords: Comparative, Law, Transsexuality, Indonesia, Iran

Abstract

This writing aims to legal reconstruction the law in Indonesia where the Islamic Republic of Iran is a comparison country. The method used is a functional method in comparative law through the approach of legal institutions and bodies of norms. Based on this legal comparison, it was found that homosexuality is an act that is very contrary to religious and cultural norms and common sense, so transsexuality with very strict terms and conditions is an urgent solution. Indonesia and Iran only recognize two genders, namely male and female. However, in Indonesia, it is not specifically regulated regarding lesbian, homosexual, and transsexual sexual acts. The existence of different judicial decisions in Indonesia regarding transsexuals shows that these decisions do not meet the elements of jurisprudence. In addition, the absence of laws and regulations specifically regulating transsexuals necessitates the absence of legal standardization of basic norms in the state so that the Constitutional Court cannot carry out its function as the protector of human rights and the final interpreter of the constitution. There needs to be an association under the auspices of the government that specifically handles sexual disorders and transsexual issues. In addition, considering that the main source of law in countries with a civil law tradition is the law (formal rules), it is necessary to establish a law that specifically regulates transsexuals as a manifestation of the principle of legal certainty and the principle of consensus as well as legal standardization of actions, handling, regulations, and legal consequences imposed on transsexual issues.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Agususanto, Toha Andiko, Lim Fahima, ‘Perubahan Status dan Akibat Hukum Pelaku Transgender Terhadap Kewarisan Dalam Perspektif Fikih Empat Mazhab’, Qiyas Volume 5, (2020)

al-Hilli, Muhaqqiq, Al-Ma'arij fi usul al-fiqh, (Qum: Muassasah Ahl Al-Bayt A.S, 1404 H)

Amin, Ismail, ‘LGBT dalam Penerapan Hukum Positif Iran’, (Ahlulbayt News Agency, 2016), <https://id.abna24.com/cultural/paper/archieve/2016/02/29/737833/story.html>, [accesses 3 October 2020]

Barford, Vanessa, ‘Iran's diagnosed transsexuals’, BBC News, 2008, <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/7259057.stm>, [accesses 27 September 2020]

Cruz, Peter De, Comparative Law in A Changing World (Cavendish Publishing Limited 1999)

Damayanti, Rita, Pandangan Lesbian, Gay, dan Biseksual (LGB) Terhadap Status Gender dan Persamaan Hak Asasi Manusia di Jakarta, Bogor, Depok, dan Tangerang, 2015 (Kementerian Pemberdayaan Perempuan dan Perlindungan Anak, Pusat Penelitian Kesehatan Universitas Indonesia, 2015).

Ernest, Yogi, ‘Penjelasan Polisi Soal Penyebutan Beda Kelamin Lucinta Luna di KTP-Paspor’, accessed June 20, (detik.com, 2020), <https://news.detik.com/berita/d-4898123/penjelasan-polisi-soal-penyebutan-beda-kelamin-lucinta-luna-di-ktp-paspor/2>,

[accesses 20 June 2022]

Ewald, William, ‘Comparative Jurisprudence: What was it Like to Try a Rat?’, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, Volume 143, (1995)

Hakim, Abdul Hadi Muhammad Taqi, Fikih Islam Berdasarkan Fatwa: Ayatullah Sayyid Ali Sistani (al-Mu’ammal 2006)

Hamadani, ‘Awjibat Istiftaat’, Misistry of Health and Medical Education, 2010, <https://behdasht.gov.ir/

استفتائات-حضرت-آيـﺔ-ا···-العظمی-نوري-همداني/اگر-زني-ازدواج-كند-و-پس-از-ازدواج-تغيير-جنسيت-دهد-حكم-ازدواج-و-مهريه-او-چگونه-است؟- >

[accesses 13 December 2020]

Hashela, Rizka Noor, LGBT Dalam Perspektif Hukum Positif, (Bagian Hukum Sekretariat Daerah Kabupaten Tanah Laut, 2016), <https://www.jdih.tanahlautkab.go.id/artikel_hukum /detail/lgbt-dalam-perspektif-hukum-positif>

[accessed 05 June 2022]

Hermanto, Bagus, Nyoman Mas Aryani, Ni Luh Gede Astariyani, ‘Penegasan Kedudukan Penjelasan Suatu Undang-Undang Tafsir Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi’, Legislasi Indonesia Volume 17, (2020)

Hocke, Van, Methodology of Legal Research (Semantic Scholar 2015)

Iranian Association for Supporting Patients with Sexual Disorders, (Ministry of Cooperatives Labour and Social Welfare, 2007), <https://asibha.mcls.gov.ir/fa/ ghorop/ts/manabeejtemae/anjomanehemayatazts-

< انجمن-حمایت-از-مبتلایان-به-اختلال-هویت-جنسی-ایران

[accesses 13 December 2020]

Iranian Association for Supporting Patients with Sexual Disorders, (Ministry of Cooperatives Labour and Social Welfare, 2007), < Error! Hyperlink reference not valid.

< شرایط-تغییر-جنسیت-در-ایران-تمایل-بیشتر-مردان-برای-زن-شدن

[accesses 13 December 2020]

Khamenei, Sayyid Ali, ‘Awjibat Istiftaat’, (The Office of The Supreme Leader, 2018), <https://www.leader.ir/en/content/21708/Gender-change>

[accesses 15 December 2020]

Khamenei, Sayyid Ali, Same-Sex Families, A New Challenge in The Western World, (Khamenei.ir, 2020), <https://english.khamenei.ir/news/7816/Same-sex-families-a-new-challenge-in-the-Western-world>,

[accessed 05 June 2022]

Lundmark, Thomas, Charting The Devide Between Common and Civil Law (Oxford University Press 2012)

Machmudin, Dudu Muswara, Pengantar Ilmu Hukum Sebuah Sketsa (Refika Aditama 2010)

Manucehri, Abbas, Sistem Politik Republik Islam Iran: Sebuah Model Penyelenggaraan Politik Ilahi, (Yogyakarta: Rausyanfikr Institute 2019)

Mertokusumo, Sudikno, Mengenal Hukum; Suatu Pengantar (Liberty 2005)

Najmabadi, Afasaneh, ‘Transing and Transpassing Across Sex-Gender Walls in Iran’, Women's Studies Quarterly, Volume 36, (2008)

Noojavan, Davood, ﺟﻨﺴﻴﺖ ﺗﻐﻴﻴﺮ ﺣﻘﻮﻗﻲ و ﻓﻘﻬﻲ ﻣﺒﺎﻧﻲ , Iranian Journal of Medical Law, Volume 3, (2009)

Partners, Brian J. Grim, The Future of Global Muslims Population (Pew Research Center 2011)

Samuel, An Introduction to Comparative Law Theory and Method (Oxford: Hart Publishing 2014)

Shirazi, Makarim, Awjibat Istiftaat, (Misistry of Health and Medical Education, 2010), <https://behdasht.gov.ir/

استفتائات-حضرت-آيـﺔ-ا···-العظمی-مكارم-شيرازي-(مدظله-العالي)/اگر-يكى-از-زوجين-تغيير-جنسيّت-دهد-لطفاً-بفرماييد···>

[accesses 13 December 2020]

The Tehran Times, ‘Iran grants $6,000 to transsexuals for treatment’, (Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, 2018), <https://www.tehrantimes.com/news/423465/Iran-grants-6-000-to-transsexuals-for-treatment>, [accesses 3 October 2020]

Thalib, Prawitra, ‘Distinction of Characteristics Sharia and Fiqh on Islamic Law’, Yuridika Fakultas Hukum Universitas Airlangga Journal, Volume 33, (2018)

Tasrif, S. Bunga Rampai: Filsafat Hukum, (Abrdin CV, 1987)

Tohid, Mirkhani, Qawanin va Syarayat Taghire Jinsiyyat, (Farhange Tafahom, 2022), <https://farhangetafahom.ir/transgender>

[accessed 05 June 2022]

Wati, Dyan Mardika, Jadmiko Anom Husodo, 'Perlindungan Hukum Bagi Transgeder Ditinjau dari Perspektif Hak Asasi Manusia', Res Publica, Volume 02, (2018)

Zare, Maliheh, ‘An Overview of Iranian Legal System and Research, Private and Islamic Law’ (Hauser Global Law School Program, 2013), <https://www.nyulawglobal.org/globalex /Iran_Legal_System_Research.html>,

[accesses 27 September 2020]

Published
2022-07-30
Section
Articles